CitytisticsShortlist
Migration · Putnam County, New York

Who moves to Lake Carmel, and where they go.

Lake Carmel sits in Putnam County, New York. In 2022 to 2023, 4,640 people moved into the county from other counties and 4,903 moved out, so it lost about 263 people to moves, or 3.0 for every 1,000 people who live there. That leaves it behind 76% of US counties.

Moved in
4,640
people, 2022 to 2023
Moved out
4,903
people
Net
−263
−3.0 per 1,000 people on tax returns
Income per household
$97,000
newcomers, vs $107,000 for leavers

At a glance

The things that matter most about moves in and out of Putnam County.

The verdict
−263

In 2022 to 2023, more people moved out than in. For every 100 who left, 95 arrived.

How it ranks
24%

of US counties grew less from moves. It ranks 35th of 57 counties in New York.

Who is moving
−$10,000

Households moving in earn $97,000 a year on average, less than the $107,000 of those leaving.

How far they come
18 mi

Half of newcomers from the top counties moved less than 18 miles. 82% came from under 50 miles away.

The rent gap
10%

of newcomers from the top counties left places where rent is higher. Rent there averages $1,779 a month, vs $1,931 in Mahopac.

Local or not
20%

of newcomers came from another state. 80% moved from elsewhere in New York.

The trend
2022

It turned to losing people in 2022 to 2023.

What it means

The story of moves in Putnam County, in plain words.

Its biggest partner is Westchester County: 1,890 people came from there and 1,026 went there. On balance it gains the most from Westchester County (864 more in than out) and loses the most to Dutchess County (369 more out than in).

Most moves are short. Among the top counties, half of newcomers came from less than 18 miles away, and 70% of people who left stayed within 50 miles.

The people leaving tend to earn more than the people arriving: $107,000 a year per household against $97,000. The county is losing some of its higher earners. The highest-earning newcomers come from New York County, at $244,000 per household.

Newcomers are not chasing cheaper rent here: most come from places where rent is lower than the $1,931 a month in Mahopac. Jobs, family or schools likely matter more. Of the people who left, 78% went somewhere cheaper.

Looking back to 2017 to 2018, 5% fewer people move in each year now. Its best year was 2019 to 2020 (+374) and its worst was 2018 to 2019 (−332). It turned to losing people in 2022 to 2023.

For context, the New York metro area lost 10.9 people per 1,000 from moves with other metros, and New York as a whole lost 10.3 per 1,000 from moves with other states. So Putnam County is doing better than its state.

The map

Teal lines bring people in. Orange lines take people away. Thicker means more people. Hover a line for the count.

Westchester County, NY: 1,890 moved to Putnam CountyWestchester County, NY: 1,026 moved here from Putnam CountyDutchess County, NY: 716 moved here from Putnam CountyBronx County, NY: 488 moved to Putnam CountyDutchess County, NY: 347 moved to Putnam CountyNew York County, NY: 221 moved to Putnam CountyQueens County, NY: 216 moved to Putnam CountyNew York County, NY: 163 moved here from Putnam CountyKings County, NY: 150 moved to Putnam CountyBronx County, NY: 130 moved here from Putnam CountyQueens County, NY: 84 moved here from Putnam CountyHorry County, SC: 84 moved here from Putnam CountyOrange County, NY: 77 moved to Putnam CountySuffolk County, NY: 73 moved to Putnam CountyKings County, NY: 71 moved here from Putnam CountyOrange County, NY: 71 moved here from Putnam CountyNassau County, NY: 64 moved to Putnam CountyUlster County, NY: 63 moved here from Putnam CountyPalm Beach County, FL: 57 moved here from Putnam CountyRockland County, NY: 53 moved here from Putnam CountyRockland County, NY: 46 moved to Putnam CountyLos Angeles County, CA: 38 moved here from Putnam CountyBergen County, NJ: 33 moved to Putnam CountyHudson County, NJ: 33 moved here from Putnam CountyNassau County, NY: 31 moved here from Putnam CountySuffolk County, NY: 29 moved here from Putnam CountySuffolk County, MA: 27 moved here from Putnam CountyWestchester County, NYBronx County, NYDutchess County, NYNew York County, NYQueens County, NYKings County, NYOrange County, NYSuffolk County, NYNassau County, NYRockland County, NYBergen County, NJWestchester County, NYDutchess County, NYNew York County, NYBronx County, NYQueens County, NYHorry County, SCKings County, NYOrange County, NYUlster County, NYPalm Beach County, FLRockland County, NYLos Angeles County, CAHudson County, NJNassau County, NYSuffolk County, NYSuffolk County, MAPutnam CountyWestchesterWestchesterBronxBronxDutchessDutchessNew YorkNew YorkPutnamPutnam
Moved in fromMoved out toLine width is people. Top counties only.

Explore the counties

Every county on the top lists, plotted by how far away it is, what its movers earn, or what rent costs there. Switch between newcomers and leavers, filter by distance, and click a bubble.

10050050 miMiles away (log scale)People

Showing 11 of 12 counties and 3,852 people. Hover a bubble for its numbers, or click it to see what it means. Bigger bubbles mean more people.

The counties behind the chart

Where newcomers came from
Westchester CountyNY1,89018$89,635$1,784−147
Bronx CountyNY48840$85,612n/an/a
Dutchess CountyNY34723$72,284$1,400−531
Western Connecticut Planning RegiCT247n/a$89,049$2,276+345
New York CountyNY22146$244,038n/an/a
Queens CountyNY21650$114,085n/an/a
Kings CountyNY15055$117,106$1,821−110
Orange CountyNY7729$71,383$1,604−327
Suffolk CountyNY7361$106,093$1,660−271
Nassau CountyNY6448$94,200$1,622−309

The top 12 counties account for 83% of newcomers and the top 18 for 65% of leavers. The rest came from or went to places too small for the IRS to list. Miles are straight-line distances between county centers. Rent is the median in each county's largest city.

Follow the flow

Left: where newcomers came from. Middle: Putnam County. Right: where leavers went. Gray bands are everyone outside the top counties.

Moved in fromMoved out toWestchester to Putnam County: 1,890 people (41% of arrivals)Bronx to Putnam County: 488 people (11% of arrivals)Dutchess to Putnam County: 347 people (7% of arrivals)Western Connecticut Planning Regi, CT to Putnam County: 247 people (5% of arrivals)New York to Putnam County: 221 people (5% of arrivals)Queens to Putnam County: 216 people (5% of arrivals)Rest of New York to Putnam County: 534 people (12% of arrivals)Other states to Putnam County: 697 people (15% of arrivals)Putnam County to Westchester: 1,026 people (21% of leavers)Putnam County to Dutchess: 716 people (15% of leavers)Putnam County to Western Connecticut Planning Regi, CT: 463 people (9% of leavers)Putnam County to New York: 163 people (3% of leavers)Putnam County to Bronx: 130 people (3% of leavers)Putnam County to Queens: 84 people (2% of leavers)Putnam County to Rest of New York: 526 people (11% of leavers)Putnam County to Other states: 1,752 people (36% of leavers)Putnam County to Abroad: 43 people (1% of leavers)Westchester1,890 · 41%Bronx488 · 11%Dutchess347 · 7%Western Connecticut Planning Regi, CT247 · 5%New York221 · 5%Queens216 · 5%Rest of New York534 · 12%Other states697 · 15%Westchester1,026 · 21%Dutchess716 · 15%Western Connecticut Planning Regi, CT463 · 9%New York163 · 3%Bronx130 · 3%Queens84 · 2%Rest of New York526 · 11%Other states1,752 · 36%Abroad43 · 1%Putnam4,640 in · 4,903 out
Top counties people came fromTop counties people left forEveryone else, by where

Year by year

Press Play to watch 6 years of moves, or tap a year. Watch 2022 to 2023, when it turned to losing people.

Moved in4,640
Moved out4,903
−263net, −3.0 per 1,000

2022 to 2023: 4,640 moved in and 4,903 moved out, so Putnam County lost 263 people. That is the year it turned to losing people.

Newcomers vs leavers

The people arriving and the people leaving, side by side.

MeasureNewcomersLeavers
People4,6404,903
Income per household$97K$107K
Half moved less than18 miles23 miles
Moved within New York80%54%
Rent where they came from or went$1,779$1,743

Rent in Mahopac, the largest city in Putnam County, is $1,931 a month. Rent where people came from or went is averaged over the top counties, weighted by people.

Gains the most from

  1. Westchester County, NY +864
  2. Bronx County, NY +358
  3. Queens County, NY +132

How it compares

People gained or lost to moves for every 1,000 residents. Putnam County grew more than 24% of US counties and ranks 35th of 57 in New York.

Against its metro area and state

  1. Putnam County−3.0
  2. New York metro area−10.9
  3. New York−10.3

The metro area counts moves with other metro areas, and the state counts moves with other states, so each uses its own yardstick.

Against counties with about as many movers

  1. Chatham County, NC+25.4
  2. Tooele County, UT+19.6
  3. Miami County, OH+6.1
  4. Androscoggin County, ME+4.5
  5. Walworth County, WI+1.7
  6. Putnam County, NY−3.0
  7. Monongalia County, WV−3.2
  8. Montgomery County, VA−8.3

Of 432 US counties with a similar number of people moving in and out, Putnam County ranks 362nd for growth from moves.

County by county

The top counties both ways, with the net for each.

Where people come from and where they go, top counties

Bronx County, NY488130+358
New York County, NY221163+58
Queens County, NY21684+132

Within New York, other states or abroad

Arrivals
Leavers
Within New YorkOther statesAbroad

Income per tax return

Arrivals$97K
Leavers$107K

People on tax returns who moved between counties, from the IRS. Figures are for all of Putnam County. Flows under 20 returns are not published, so small places can be missing. Method.

Questions people ask

Straight answers about moving to and from Lake Carmel.

Are people moving to Lake Carmel, NY?

More are leaving than arriving. In 2022 to 2023, 4,640 people moved to Putnam County and 4,903 moved away, a net loss of about 263. Its growth from moves beats 24% of US counties.

Where are people moving to Lake Carmel from?

The most came from Westchester County (1,890), Bronx County (488), Dutchess County (347). 20% came from another state.

Where are people from Lake Carmel moving to?

The most went to Westchester County (1,026), Dutchess County (716), Western Connecticut Planning Regi, CT (463). 54% stayed in New York.

Do people moving to Lake Carmel earn more than people leaving?

No, the people leaving earn more. Households moving in average $97,000 a year and households moving out average $107,000, based on income on their tax returns.

Is Lake Carmel growing or shrinking from moves?

It lost people to moves in 2022 to 2023. Over 6 years, net moves ranged from −332 to +374 a year.

How does Lake Carmel compare with other places in New York?

Putnam County ranks 35th of 57 New York counties for growth from moves (−3.0 per 1,000 people). The state as a whole was −10.3 per 1,000 from moves with other states.

How far do people move to get to Lake Carmel?

Not far, for most. Half of newcomers from the top counties came from less than 18 miles away, and half of leavers moved less than 23 miles.

Where to next

Pages that go deeper on Lake Carmel and the places linked to it.

The wider New York metro area lost about 174,207 people to moves with other metro areas in 2022 to 2023 (−10.9 per 1,000). Most of its newcomers came from Philadelphia. See the New York metro's moves

Keep exploring