CitytisticsShortlist
Citytistics/Schools/Methodology

Public methodology / School Index v2 · November 2026

A school is more than a number.

We publish the source components, exact math, data coverage and comparison groups behind every Citytistics School Index score.

National directory versus academic ratings

Citytistics maintains two distinct evidence layers. The national directory uses NCES school-level identity, grade, location and staffing records from the Common Core of Data (public and charter schools, 2024-25) and the Private School Universe Survey (2023-24). The directory can identify schools and provide useful logistics without inventing academic results.

Georgia is our first completed state-accountability model, using its published CCRPI source components. We do not apply Georgia's academic formula to schools elsewhere or imply that proficiency tests in different states share the same cut scores. Private schools frequently have no comparable public accountability results; missing scores remain unrated rather than being penalized.

Basic nationwide directory pages remain noindex until they contain enough school-specific outcomes, program information and original insight to be useful independent search results. State directories and Georgia's evidence-rich profiles are discoverable. The national data source files are versioned and refreshed in validated, state-level bundles.

Why there is no perfect school score

A published source component can mathematically equal 100. So can a weighted average of those components. But neither establishes a perfect learning environment. Citytistics now uses the empirical grade-band peer percentile as the primary comparative headline, with a midrank method that never reaches the 100th percentile. The separately labeled weighted outcomes index remains available so users can audit the exact inputs.

The peer percentile is descriptive: it cannot quantify individual student fit, college readiness, safety, special-education services, arts offerings, classroom climate, or the causal impact of teachers. Scores of schools in different states must not be mistaken for nationally comparable ranks. Personal priority lenses recalculate peer percentiles within Georgia for the selected weighting.

The visual School Index and geographic rankings

The largest index on a Georgia public school page is our 0-99 grade-band peer position, calculated from the school's independently weighted academic component index (0-100). We use an empirical midrank method: schools with tied component indexes share the same position. The relative position cannot equal 100, because no school is literally perfect. The raw weighted components and observed-data coverage remain separately visible.

State, county, city and district rankings compare schools with a reported score in the same grade band and year, using the weighted academic index as the ranking value. Rank = 1 + the number of schools scoring strictly higher. Ties share rank; the next rank reflects the number ahead. The denominator includes only rated schools in that scope.

County and city membership come from exact school-identity matches to NCES, requiring both the school name and district. Unmatched and ambiguous records are excluded from local ranking denominators, rather than guessing a location. The city is the school's mailing municipality, not an attendance boundary. The rank is a relative view of the measured outcomes, not proof of which school will best serve a child.

Our Growth Advantage signal is the reported student-growth peer percentile minus the content-mastery peer percentile within the same Georgia grade band. It highlights schools whose growth performance is higher or lower than their achievement position. This does not statistically adjust for student backgrounds and does not estimate the causal effect of attending a school.

Private-school intelligence and staffing access

Private schools are included in state and city discovery. We use the NCES 2023-24 Private School Universe Survey public-use file to publish school-level enrollment, teacher counts and student-teacher ratios where reported and verified by NCES identity. Missing values remain missing.

We calculate a separate Staffing Access Index (0-99), only when at least 30 private schools with plausible reported ratios can be compared in the same state. A lower student-teacher ratio earns a higher peer position, with half credit for ties: floor[100 × (number of higher ratios + half of equal ratios) / number of peers]. We exclude extreme ratios below 2 or above 35 from the comparative cohort because unusual staffing configurations require a different context. Exact survey ratios remain visible without assigning a rating where that cohort is unavailable.

Private-school staffing ranks are separately displayed at the state, county and city level when at least three surveyed schools have comparable ratios. These comparisons include different grade levels, program models and student populations, so they are not academic or overall school-quality scores. A low ratio is not equivalent to a small class, effective instruction, or a better school. There is no fabricated private-school academic index and no ranking of private schools against public-school standardized test results.

What this rating means

Georgia's College and Career Ready Performance Index (CCRPI) publishes separate school-level measurements. Citytistics creates its own transparent weighted summary of those components. Our 0-100 score is not a government-issued grade, a forecast for a child, or a measure of teacher quality.

We deliberately emphasize student progress over raw proficiency. A school with more economically disadvantaged students must not automatically be treated as a worse school. Neighborhood wealth, race, disability composition, household income and adult educational attainment are not negative inputs to this index.

Exact weights

Source componentElementaryMiddleHigh
Academic mastery30%30%25%
Student progress35%35%30%
Closing gaps20%20%15%
Readiness15%15%15%
Graduation0%0%15%

Formula: sum of each reported 0-100 component multiplied by its published weight, divided by the total weight of the reported components. We display one decimal place. A rating is only computed when both content mastery and progress are present, at least three component scores are available and those components cover at least 75% of the default weight.

For high schools, Georgia publishes graduation rate as a fraction; we convert it to a 0-100 figure before weighting. Missing and suppressed values remain missing, never zero. A partially observed index receives a lower evidence-confidence label rather than being presented as fully complete.

Peer comparison and momentum

State percentile: compare each rated school only against other Georgia schools in its own grade band using the same default model and source year. We count schools below the given index and assign half credit for tied values, divided by the number of rated peers. Percentiles are descriptive ranks, not a probability that one school is better.

Change over time: apply the same model to compatible school-level source components in 2023, 2024 and 2025. Because Georgia's 2024 Closing Gaps component omitted mathematics and 2025 includes it, we explicitly exclude Closing Gaps from the comparable academic-core historical series. Trend charts use the consistent 2024-2025 mastery, progress and readiness components, and graduation for high schools, rather than a misleading subtraction of noncomparable full composite scores. The exact comparison years are displayed on each profile. If no comparable year exists, the trend is not displayed.

Your priorities: the directory's lenses recompute weighted scores directly from the same reported components. When you change the weights, the custom index and peer percentile are recalculated for every eligible Georgia school in the selected grade band. Neither is an official state rating.

School climate is a separate signal

We display the Georgia Department of Education's official 2025 School Climate Star Rating as published, on its own 1-5 star scale. It is not a Citytistics score, is not blended into the academic index, and is not an individual measure of safety or student well-being.

Georgia revised its School Climate Star Rating method for the 2024-25 school year and designated it a Hold Harmless year. The 2025 quarter-star results are not methodologically comparable with 2024's whole-star scores. We therefore show no climate trend. Missing official stars are labeled Not rated. Read the source and methodology caveats.

Known limitations

  • Georgia public schools are the first rated cohort. We do not assign an invented nationwide rating or compare different states' tests as though they were identical.
  • Some schools have suppressed, missing or incomplete indicators. Not rated means insufficient evidence, not poor performance.
  • State component definitions may evolve. Trends use only compatible years; older CCRPI formats must not be merged into the same series.
  • Changes in school IDs, grade configuration, accountability definitions or student composition can affect year-over-year comparisons.
  • School size, individual pupil growth distributions, class environment, safety, special education quality, extracurricular programs, attendance zones and family needs are not yet modeled. Evidence confidence is about reported component completeness, not a statistical confidence interval or causal estimate.
  • Grade-level outcome differences and local program offerings require primary-source verification. This score should be a starting point for questions, not the final decision.

Provenance and credit

Primary publisher: Georgia Department of Education CCRPI reports. Structured school-level records: Georgia Civic Data, CCRPI scores and components, cleaned and documented under CC BY 4.0 (attribution to Georgia Civic Data and the original source). The relevant cohorts are the 2023-2025 CCRPI score-era data.

All scores use publicly reported aggregates. We do not purchase school placement, change ratings for advertisers, or infer private-school quality from missing test data. Citytistics is not affiliated with Georgia's education agencies.

Return to individual school ratings