CitytisticsShortlist
Trust

Moderation policy.

How we decide which resident reviews and ratings appear on a city page. The same written rules apply to every submission, whatever its rating.

The short version

  • Every decision is made automatically by these rules. Nobody picks which reviews to show, and nobody can pay to change one.
  • A negative review is never removed for being negative. Low ratings count exactly like high ones.
  • Each review is tied to an email address that receives a one-time code, so one person gets one review per place.

What a review must be

  • About a place the reviewer lives in now or lived in before, from their own experience.
  • Written by the person sending it, with no payment or reward for writing it.
  • Between 80 and 1,500 characters if it has written comments. Ratings can be sent without comments.

What is not allowed

  • Naming, describing or criticizing a private person, such as a neighbor, landlord or business owner.
  • Phone numbers, email addresses, web links or any other contact details.
  • Profanity, threats, insults or harassment.
  • Describing residents by race, color, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sex, sexual orientation, disability or family status, or saying who should or should not live there because of any of those.
  • Advertising or promotion, including for a home, business, agent or service.
  • Text copied from another review or another site, or a repeat of the same review.
  • Comments that are not about living in the place.

A review that breaks one of these rules is not published, and the reviewer is told which rule so they can fix it.

Checks against fake and bulk reviews

  • Each submission gets a score from signals such as a confirmed email address, a passed automated visitor check, a passed content check and whether the ratings agree with each other. Only submissions that reach the required score are published.
  • New reviews wait 7 days before their ratings count toward a place's averages, so a sudden wave of ratings cannot move them overnight.
  • When many reviews or poll answers reach one place in a short time, they still show, but their ratings are left out of the averages.
  • Each person can send a limited number of reviews per day, and if submissions across the site spike far above normal, new submissions pause for a day.

Averages and shares

A place shows an average rating once at least 5 residents have rated it, and a share who would recommend living there once at least 10 have answered, rounded to the nearest 5%. Ratings older than 5 years stop counting. Until a place reaches these minimums, we show the reviews themselves and no average.

Reporting a review

Every new review has a Report link. A review is hidden when 3 different readers report it. A report that a review identifies a private person, or must be removed for a legal reason, hides it at once after the reporter confirms an email address. Reports that a review is simply negative or that the reader disagrees with it are not grounds to hide it.

Removing your own review

Anyone can delete everything they sent with one email address on Delete my submissions.

Reviews from our earlier site

Reviews written on citytistics.com before 2026 were checked once under the rule described in our methodology, and are marked as coming from our earlier site.

Last updated November 20, 2026.