CitytisticsShortlist

Carlisle, PA vs Rutherford, PA

Carlisle

Pennsylvania

vs

Rutherford

Pennsylvania

Across 34 directional measures we can compare, Carlisle leads on 21 and Rutherford on 13. Counting measures is not an overall verdict: their importance depends on your priorities. Median rent is 6% higher in Rutherford, and so is median household income.

Median gross rent
$1,094$1,155
Carlisle is 5% lower
Median household income
$61,720$83,636
Carlisle is 26% lower
Median home value
$224,100$214,200
Carlisle is 5% higher

The Citytistics read

  • After the median rent, with other prices set to the US average, the median household has about $49,000 a year left in Carlisle and $70,400 in Rutherford. Money goes further in Rutherford, by about $21,400 a year.
  • A household earning Carlisle's median of $61,720 would need about $62,500 in Rutherford to keep the same money after rent and local prices.
  • Between the 2019 and 2024 surveys, rent outran pay by 0.4 points a year in Carlisle, and pay outran rent by 6.1 points a year in Rutherford.

How these are calculated

PennsylvaniaRutherford, PACarlisle, PACarlisleRutherfordCarlisleRutherford

Cost of living, side by side

Carlisle and Rutherford cost about the same to live in.

What $1,000 of living costs in Carlisle costs in Rutherford
$1,010
Rent, groceries, gas and the rest, together.
Pay you need in Rutherford to live like $61,720 in Carlisle
$62,000
$61,720 is the typical household income in Carlisle.

Typical rent: $1,094 a month in Carlisle, $1,155 in Rutherford. Cost of living index, where 100 is the US average: Carlisle 95, Rutherford 96. How it works · Find places that fit your budget

Which fits you?

Both start on the Citytistics Index (CTX). Move the sliders to weigh what matters to you and the score becomes your own mix.

Your weights

Top 2 of 2 matching places. Scores are real scores on fixed scales: 70 and up is Good, 40 to 69 Fair, under 40 Poor.

#PlaceCTXAffordabilityEconomyEducationSafetyCommuteAmenitiesGrowth
01Carlisle, PA
68
68535684865881
02Rutherford, PA
64
906425n/a8043n/a

CTX is the Citytistics Index, a 0 to 100 score on fixed scales, not a percentile: 70 and up is Good, 40 to 69 Fair, under 40 Poor. Change any weight to rank on your own mix. How the CTX is built

Every measure

The dots show where each place sits among the 6,645 places we track. The bar is the median. A small dot after a value marks the better one.

MeasureCarlisleRutherfordAmong all places
Cost of living
Median gross rent1$1,094$1,155
Rent to income121.3%16.6%
Property tax rate11.5%1.3%
Home price to income13.6x2.6x
Prices vs US average298.798.7
Fair market rent, 2 bedrooms3$1,598$1,598
HUD area median income4$109,300$109,300
Housing
Property tax paid (median)1$3,444$2,685
Median home value1$224,100$214,200
Home prices, 1-year change53.9%5.2%
Home prices, 5-year change550.0%53.9%
Homeownership148.7%74.8%
Renters paying 30%+154.2%68.8%
Owner costs with a mortgage1$1,551$1,456
Vacant homes16.1%0.0%
Median year built119531980
Jobs and income
Median household income1$61,720$83,636
Income per person1$39,339$35,253
Unemployment14.4%4.5%
Average annual pay6$65,962$69,570
Pay growth, 1 year61.2%2.3%
Jobs6137,858190,394
Poverty rate115.1%8.3%
Mean commute119 min20 min
Works from home19.9%16.8%
Commutes by transit10.2%0.0%
People
Population121,8526,890
Population change since 2020712.8%n/a
Median age135.834.8
Bachelor's or higher137.9%22.6%
High school or higher193.6%81.4%
Household size12.02.8
Born abroad17.9%21.4%
No health insurance15.6%6.4%
Homes with broadband189.4%96.6%
Moving
Moved here in the past year112.7%6.5%
Moved from another state13.5%2.0%
Net movers per 1,000 people810.2-2.6
Income of households moving in8$66,639$56,063
Income of households moving out8$71,719$63,305
Local life
Restaurants and bars per 10k919.521.2
Shops per 10k931.030.5
Arts, recreation and fitness per 10k93.44.7
Doctors' offices and clinics per 10k922.419.9
Child care centers per 10k92.13.6
Parks per 10k1011.911.6
Playgrounds per 10k1010.12.9
Grocery stores per 10k102.84.3
Restaurants, cafes and bars per 10k1020.116.0
Libraries per 10k100.90.0
Named paths and bike trails101.50.0
Transit stops per sq mi100.20.0
Nearest National Park Service site1126.639.9
National Park Service sites within 60 miles1155
National Register listings12680
Founded or incorporated131751n/a
Safety
Violent crime per 100k14173n/a
Property crime per 100k141,062n/a
Schools
Public schools151072
Public school students155,29172,394
Students per teacher1514.314.5
Climate
July average high1686°F84°F
January average low1622°F21°F
Average temperature1653°F52°F
Annual precipitation1644.3 in46.0 in
Hazards and air
Natural hazard risk1786.291.1
Hurricane risk1787.489.2
Tornado risk1768.279.8
Wildfire risk1747.538.9
Heat wave risk1785.788.4
Median air quality index183544
Good air days1871.5%62.5%

Data bundle checked 2026-11-16; individual source vintages vary. Rent needed at the 30% line: Carlisle $43,760, Rutherford $46,200 a year.

Sources and methods

The small numbers beside each measure point here. Links go to the publisher.

  1. American Community Survey 5-year estimates · US Census Bureau · 2020 to 2024 estimatesTables B01002, B01003, B05002, B07003, B08013, B08301, B15003, B17001, B19013, B19301, B23025, B25002, B25003, B25010, B25035, B25064, B25070, B25077, B25088, B25103, B28002, S2701
  2. Regional Price Parities · US Bureau of Economic Analysis · Latest release, retrieved 2026-11-16
  3. Fair Market Rents · US Department of Housing and Urban Development · Fiscal year 2027
  4. Income Limits · US Department of Housing and Urban Development · Fiscal year 2026
  5. House Price Index · Federal Housing Finance Agency · Latest release, retrieved 2026-11-16
  6. Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages · US Bureau of Labor Statistics · 2025 annual averages
  7. Population Estimates · US Census Bureau · Vintage 2025
  8. SOI Tax Stats, county-to-county migration · Internal Revenue Service · Tax years 2022 to 2023Counts tax returns and the people on them; flows under 20 returns are suppressed.
  9. County Business Patterns · US Census Bureau · 2023 data
  10. OpenStreetMap · © OpenStreetMap contributors, available under the Open Database License (ODbL) · Map data as of 2026-11
  11. National Park Service sites · Wikidata (CC0), units operated by the National Park Service · Retrieved 2026-11
  12. National Register of Historic Places · National Park Service · Listings through 2026-05-22
  13. Wikidata · Wikimedia Foundation (CC0) · Retrieved 2026-11
  14. Crime Data Explorer · Federal Bureau of Investigation · 2025 data
  15. Common Core of Data · National Center for Education Statistics · 2024 release
  16. 1991-2020 climate normals · NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information · Series updated 2026-11-05Averages for 1991 to 2020 computed from NOAA's county climate series (nClimDiv).nClimDiv county series
  17. National Risk Index · Federal Emergency Management Agency · Latest release, retrieved 2026-11-16NRI data and maps
  18. Air Quality System, annual AQI by county · US Environmental Protection Agency · 2025 dataAirData download files

Derived by Citytistics from the tables above: rent to income (B25064, B19013); property tax rate (B25103, B25077); home price to income (B25077, B19013).

Survey figures are estimates with margins of error. Formulas and definitions: methodology.

Keep comparing

Other places people weigh against these two, and each one in full.

Carlisle vs Rutherford: cost of living, rent and jobs compared | Citytistics