CitytisticsShortlist
Calculator

Should you rent or buy?

Find the year buying starts to cost less than renting in your city. It starts from local prices, rents and taxes, and you can change every assumption.

Change the assumptions
Break-even
29 years

Buying in New York costs less than renting once you stay 29 years or longer. If you stay 7 years, renting comes out about $176,760 ahead.

Owning, a month
$5,448
mortgage $3,932 plus tax, insurance, upkeep
Renting, a month
$1,821
this year
Cash to buy
$178,848
down payment and closing
Break-even, year 29Renting cheaperBuying cheaperYear 1Year 10Year 20Year 30
Owning minus renting, total cost so far. The line crosses zero at break-even. The dark dot is how long you said you would stay.

Method: owning cost so far = cash to buy + every mortgage, tax, insurance and upkeep payment, minus what you would keep after selling. Renting cost so far = every rent payment, minus what the cash to buy would have earned invested. Home price, rent and property tax start from Census and FHFA figures for New York; home price growth starts from its last five years. Mortgage rate is an assumption: set it to a rate you were quoted. Tax deductions and PMI are left out.

Where the numbers come from

Median home value and median rent are from the US Census Bureau's American Community Survey. The property tax rate is the median real estate tax divided by the median home value, from the same survey. Home price growth starts from the city's FHFA House Price Index over the last five years, shown as a yearly rate and kept between 0% and 6%. The mortgage rate, insurance, upkeep, investment return and buying and selling costs are common planning assumptions, not local data. How we build the data.

More tools